Unusual wedding song requests we have actually received

Requested once

Not every great reception moment is a top-100 title. These five were each requested just once, and they are unusual in a way a guest would remember fondly.

We pulled these from songs that appeared exactly once on a must-play, play-if-you-can, or guest-request list, then kept only the ones that felt genuinely charming — nothing explicit, nothing mean, nothing that reads like a typo of a hit. They are not a ranked chart. They are five reminders that your list can include something only you would ask for.

If you have a similarly odd favorite, put it on your must-play or play-if-you-can list with the title and artist. We would rather see it written down than guessed from a nickname.

  1. 1Banana PancakesJack Johnson

    A soft, Sunday-morning Jack Johnson song that one couple asked for anyway — unhurried, warm, and not a typical reception request.

    Requested once
  2. 2Thank You for Being a FriendAndrew Gold

    The Golden Girls theme, asked for once and easy to smile at — familiar, kind, and not a typical reception request.

    Requested once
  3. 3Honey and the MoonJoseph Arthur

    A pretty, slightly hidden Joseph Arthur song. One of those titles a couple has to know, which is exactly why it belongs on a short list of unusual requests.

    Requested once
  4. 4I Love YouBarney

    Yes, the Barney song. One couple asked for it, and it is hard not to smile at that. Unusual, harmless, and very much a story.

    Requested once
  5. 5Chocolate and RosesThe Green

    A sweet, low-key song by The Green that almost never appears on wedding lists. Quiet, specific, and easy to love if it is already yours.

    Requested once

Questions couples ask

Can we request a song that is not a typical wedding song?

Yes. Some of the best nights include one title that only you would have picked. Write the title and artist on your list so we can plan a place for it.

Will you play a funny or novelty song if we ask?

If it is on your must-play list and it is appropriate for the room you asked us to build, yes. If it would empty the floor or clash with a do-not-play, we will talk it through before the wedding.

How did you choose these five?

They were each requested exactly once, and we picked titles a reader would find charming rather than shocking. This is a small, editorial list, not a claim that these are the five “most unique” songs we have ever heard.

More wedding music lists

The big lists

Special dances

By era and style

You can also read the wedding DJ FAQ, browse venues we know well, or contact us about your date.